Select Sunday > Sunday Web Site Home > Music > Musical Musings

Maybe, Maybe Not

Looking at today’s Gospel, I remembered a song from the 70s—Jean Goeboro’s “Consider the Lilies”—that would have made a nice selection for Preparation of Gifts or a second Communion song.

Not so fast.

I found my copy and, of course, I had not remembered its text peculiarities. (Listen here.) The refrain and first verse are fine, but verses 2–4 have grisly off-accents: The accents are on the wrong syllable! Verse 2: The birds of the air. … in the eyes of God? Verse 3: gives clothes to his chil-dren. Verse 4: for tomorrow… Seek first His king-dom.

Oh, dear.

These days an alert editor would have made adjustments—little rhythmic jogs, a couple of pickup notes, that sort of thing—enabling singers to sing it in a way that makes sense. (Which is what I would do if I wanted to use the song for this Sunday.) And it’s a pity someone official hasn’t actually done that since 1974.

This happens in Christmas carols, such as “The First Nowell”: “This star drew nigh to the northwest …”

But it points up what I often urge: you should sing all the verses of a possibly useful song aloud—yes, aloud, to yourself, even if there’s no one else in the room. You will save yourself a lot of time. Your community won’t thank you because they don’t know what you’re doing, but you will have saved them and your singers the discomfort of an awkwardly-set text.

It’s the right thing to do.

MD Ridge
Return to Music
Art by Martin Erspamer, OSB
from Religious Clip Art for the Liturgical Year (A, B, and C).
This art may be reproduced only by parishes who purchase the collection in book or CD-ROM form. For more information go http://www.ltp.org
Return to Music